Tweaking dumb-init

I’ve been having a look at envoy, only I’ve been looking at it in docker-compose rather than kubernetes, so the usual sidecar type of deployment possible there wasn’t an option. Simply starting up one program in the background and the other in the foreground ‘works’, but not ideally. If the background process dies, the other one carries on oblivious as if nothing is wrong.

Putting in a full init system in a docker container is generally missing the point of containers. Then it occurred to me that what I really want is a dumb-init that just spins up 2 processes instead of just the one. So I adapted it and did just that. By separating the commands with a semicolon you can use dumb-init in the usual way.

Note that I’ve done nothing special about stdout/err, or well anything really, so things may not behave perfectly for your situation, but so far in my testing everything has worked far better than I could ever expect.

With this fork you start 2 processes like this,

$ ./dumb-init echo hello \; echo world

And if you try this,

$ ./dumb-init sleep 1000 \; echo test

You’ll see that it exits as soon as the echo completes, as it closes down if either process ends.

I’m not sure I really plan on doing anything serious with this fork, I’m not sure that there aren’t better alternatives that I’ve missed. I haven’t tested it much either. It looks like it does what I want, but I haven’t done any scientific testing.


Docker logging and buffering

When you start using Docker one of the things it’s quite possibly you’ve hit is output buffering. Docker encourages you to log to stdout/err from your program, and then use docker to feed your regular logging solution.

This generally exhibits itself as you seeing no logging, then after the program has been running for a while you come back to the logs and find they are all there. It doesn’t get as much press as caching but it can be just as head scratching.

With Perl for example the buffering kicks in when it’s not connected to a terminal. For that this somewhat idiomatic snippet can be useful,

select( ( select(\*STDERR), $|=1 )[0] );
select( ( select(\*STDOUT), $|=1 )[0] );

As ever with Perl there is more than one way to do it of course…

Note that you could experience this sort of thing when using other logging setups. If you pipe to logger to output to rsyslog you could experience the same issues.